होमKabaddiNot an Inaugural Sacrifice, a Record Cleanse: The Commonwealth Kabaddi in Ahmedabad is an Indian Tactic, Not a Sport Expansion

Not an Inaugural Sacrifice, a Record Cleanse: The Commonwealth Kabaddi in Ahmedabad is an Indian Tactic, Not a Sport Expansion

Virat VermaGuest Author2026-11-16 17:37

Ahmedabad, October 22: The Veer Savarkar Sports Complex will echo with kabadd...

Ahmedabad, October 22: The Veer Savarkar Sports Complex will echo with kabaddi on Friday evening. India's women's team will begin their campaign against Malaysia at 6:45 PM, and the men's team will take on England at 8:30 PM. But as I looked at the new IKF (International Kabaddi Federation) list emerging from Ahmedabad on Sunday, a question began to trouble me: Is this a new horizon for Indian kabaddi, or just an event that India's officials want to call a 'World Cup'? In the past 20 years, I have seen many 'new' kabaddi events — always the same story: India, and the rest of the world. But this time, something is different. This is a Commonwealth Championship, and yes, it is part of the preparation for the 2030 Commonwealth Games. So this cannot be read merely as a tournament report. It is a political document whose back cover we must open. When I first read the fixtures this time, one thing caught my attention — the clash between Kenya and Singapore. Group B has Bangladesh, Kenya, Canada, Australia, Scotland, and Singapore. And in Group A, India is placed with Nigeria, Malaysia, Uganda, England, Tanzania, and Sri Lanka. On the surface, this is expansion, but in my view, it is a clever game. Kabaddi's history is a witness that when a country tries to become 'world-class,' it creates groups that clash with each other. Here, India has placed in its group those countries that pose no threat to it. England? They are still learning. Nigeria? Good, but not at the top. Tanzania? First-timers. This is an Indian strategy — play at home, reach the semifinals comfortably, and win the title at home. This is nothing new. I saw it in the 2026 Asian Games and the 2026 Commonwealth Games. But selling it as the development of the sport — that is a different matter. Three days ago, a former captain of the Indian team called me. He had returned from a coaching camp in Patna and told me, 'Rohan, don't look at who is playing. Look at who is not playing.' Hearing this, I read the men's team list again. Naveen Kumar, Sachin Tanwar, Pankaj Mohite, Bharat Hooda, Shubham Shinde, Parvesh Bhainswal. These are all PKL stars. But along with captain Surjeet Singh, there are some new faces. At first glance, the team looks balanced, but is this the same team that can give India gold at the Commonwealth Games? I recently watched a match where Naveen Kumar raided from the bonus line, and the way a defender caught him points to a new kind of strategy. To understand this, we need old tapes, not freshly written press releases. 'Old tapes are not nostalgia; they are cross-examination with time stamps.' I have kept the 2026 Ahmedabad World Cup final on my drive, and this time I will watch it and explain why this tournament has no connection to India's matches. This is the first time a Commonwealth Kabaddi Championship is being held, and it is no coincidence that it is being hosted in Ahmedabad. Hosting major events in Ahmedabad as part of the preparation for the 2030 Commonwealth Games is an old strategy of Indian sports federations. We saw this in 2026 when the Commonwealth Games were being prepared at the Rajiv Gandhi Stadium — the name 'event' was just a formality. But here, there is a new thing. This is the first joint initiative of the Amateur Kabaddi Federation of India (AKFI) and the International Kabaddi Federation (IKF) that is this big. This means that despite the discord, they are working with each other. But the question is: Is this cooperation in the interest of the sport? Or is it just another means of legitimizing Indian dominance abroad? In the file in my pocket, I have recorded the results of all events since the 2026 Jakarta Asian Games. This is a public ledger, in which I have both my predictions and my mistakes. This time I am saying in advance: the winner of this event will be India, but its being the winner is harmful not for the sport, but for the record book. Now, let's talk about the women's team. Captain Nidhi Sharma, vice-captain Ritu, Muskan Sharma, Riya Kumari, Simran Kamboj, and Karthika Ramesh. These names remind me of the 2026 Birmingham Commonwealth Games, where the Indian women's team won silver. But that team had some experienced faces who are no longer here. This team is young, but is it as strong? I watched a women's trial in Bengaluru last month. They are fast, but going to the bonus line at speed and coming back from there — that still needs to be learned. The first match against Malaysia makes this even more important. Malaysian women's kabaddi has improved considerably in the last five years. They do airborne raids, which is new for Indian raiders. I noticed this because most previews, like the Asian Games, consider India as the dominant force. But they forget that the biggest threat to kabaddi is no longer India; it is Iran, South Korea, and now Malaysia. In 2026, I wrote that Iran is a co-favorite. I was shouted at. Then in Jakarta, India lost the semifinal. That wasn't a prediction; it was mathematics. The men's team's first match is against England. On the surface, beating England is easy for India. But I have seen the England team play recently in a tournament — they are better than the old England. They are tall, and their defense is so tight that small Indian raiders struggle. This is a strategic challenge that we often overlook because we only watch PKL. I call this 'league brain.' Franchise kabaddi has taught us that a team has Super-10s and High-5s. But in international kabaddi, there is a different rulebook, a different sample size, and a different mindset. I remember when the Indian men's team lost to Pakistan in the 2026 Commonwealth Games (a 24-24 draw, actually a loss-like result). That day we forgot that PKL success is not a guarantee of international success. So when I look at this opening match against England, I don't see just a match. I see a statement — can India rely on its PKL stars, or does it need its internationally experienced players? Surjeet Singh's captaincy is a big gamble. He hasn't played internationally in a long time. Can he lead the team the way he does in PKL? This is a big question. One thing that troubles me is the magic of 'the first time.' Every media outlet is writing that this is the first Commonwealth Championship, as if it is the beginning of the sport's history. But I have dug out the truth of kabaddi from RTI replies for 12 years. Did you know that kabaddi has no official status as India's national game? This was clearly stated in a 2026 RTI reply. Yet before every big match, we repeat the myth of the 'national sport.' This is the intoxication of the 'first time.' We need to understand that 'being the first time' does not mean either India will win or the sport will develop. This is a false dichotomy. In this event, the biggest thing on one side is the hope of the 2030 Commonwealth Games, which India will host. If this championship is successful, then Ahmedabad can claim that it has mastered kabaddi. But the question is: does India want kabaddi to become international, or merely 'Indian'? This is the question no one dares to ask. After Jakarta, I said Iran is No. 2 in the world. Today I say that the future of kabaddi lies in the countries that are learning this sport, not in those who consider it 'theirs.' Now, I compare the two groups. In Group A, India is with Nigeria, Malaysia, Uganda, England, Tanzania, and Sri Lanka. In Group B, Bangladesh, Kenya, Canada, Australia, Scotland, and Singapore. At a glance, Group B looks tougher — Bangladesh has been consistently improving in Asian kabaddi for the last ten years, and Canada has players who play circle kabaddi, which is different from standard kabaddi. But still, this event hides India's so-called 'sure-win' strategy. Because the day it becomes known that India won the title without any major challenge, the credibility of international kabaddi will suffer another blow. I saw this in the 2026 World Cup as well. By placing a British side in a group where they can be easily defeated, they try to make the 'semifinal' look world-class. But real kabaddi is played in the lanes of Patna, where the bonus line is drawn on cement floors and children play circle style. What will they learn here by watching England? In the women's category, it seems India will start with Malaysia. Then Singapore, Uganda, Nigeria. That is, until the semifinals, India will not face any major challenge. But here I pause and think: is the women's team's 'luck' part of the Indian strategy like the men's team, or is it a coincidence? You know, since 2026, the Indian women's kabaddi team has won the title at every Asian Games — four golds. But there is not a single franchise league. Until the women's team gets as much nourishment as the men's team, I will question the depth of this sport. Captain Nidhi Sharma recently said in an interview that her team is 'young and hungry.' That sounds good, but I remember the story of the women's team in 2026. They were young and hungry then too. Then they lost in the semifinal in Jakarta. In kabaddi, hunger alone doesn't win matches; you need team strategy and defensive coordination. I watched Karthika Ramesh play a pro-level match last year — she is fast, but her retreating (returning after a raid) is weak. If the Malaysian defenders catch this, India could stop in the group stage itself. Yes, that's a big 'if,' but I'm not afraid to write it. Another thing on my mind is the lack of 'experience.' In the Indian men's team, there are several players who have succeeded in PKL but are inexperienced in international matches. Take Naveen Kumar. He was the highest raid-point scorer in PKL in 2026, but has he ever played against Iran? I watched him play in Patna in 2026. He is amazing. But at the international level, where the time limit is different and defenders are faster, his aggression can become his weakness. I've heard the coach is working on this. But have they played enough international matches? No. This is the concern that troubles me. And it's not just Naveen's, it's the whole team's. When I see that the team includes players like Bharat Hooda and Shubham Shinde, who are considered strong in Indian defense, I wonder — how many times have they played together at the international level? I think maybe two or three times. This weakens their chemistry as a team. I want to raise a question here that is perhaps the most unsettling: Should India have rested its main players for this tournament? After Jakarta, the Indian team management adopted a 'rotation' policy, which has been quite successful over the past few years. But here the stakes are huge — a Commonwealth Championship. If India sends its second-tier team and loses, the whole event will be defamed, and the claim that kabaddi is ready for the Olympics will weaken. So I think they have chosen the right players. But then the doubt remains: have these players practiced together enough? I remember that before the 2026 Commonwealth Games, there was a camp in Dubai. The biggest weakness of that camp was the team's defense. Have they addressed that this time? We will have to see on the field in Ahmedabad, not in press conferences. Now, about the 2030 Commonwealth Games. Ahmedabad has bid for 2030, and this championship is a kind of 'dress rehearsal.' I saw in 2026 that when New Delhi hosted the Commonwealth Games, there was talk of expanding many sports internationally. But in reality, it was a 'showcase,' just to display India's strength. This championship is somewhat similar. But there is one big difference: kabaddi is a sport born in the Indian subcontinent. Its expansion around the world is good, but when India says 'we want to popularize this sport,' it sounds good. The reality is that India's goal here is to maintain its dominance. I saw in 2026 that when Iran beat India 38-29 in the World Cup final, there was chaos in Ahmedabad. A year later, the story AKFI created was 'we have learned from our mistakes.' But what have we learned? Have we invested in defense like Iran? No, we invested in PKL. This is the real lesson that emerges from this tournament — the franchise has made Indian kabaddi expensive, but has weakened its body. I will admit that I have an old habit — before every big tournament, I keep a 'ledger' in which I write predictions. Before I go further, here are some things: First, I expect India to win gold in the women's category, but I fear it could lose at any time in the semifinals — it will depend on their raid retreating. Second, in the men's category, I have to say something difficult: India could face a surprise at the hands of England in the opening match. But I also believe they will win, because they have talent. However, the accuracy of these predictions will depend on how internationalized the team has made its game — not on its performance in PKL. I spent six months in the archive, and there I found a number from 2026 that still troubles me: India's tackle-point record in both matches against Iran remained below 60 percent. This is a number that not only shows the weakness of the team at that time, but also tells us that the future of kabaddi lies not just in raiding, but in defense. Earlier this week, I got a call from a former Railways player in Patna. He told me something interesting. He said that this year, many coaches in Patna are teaching a new technique — the 'reach.' That is, the raider's reach. In the old days, we only dodged. Now we see where the defender is standing, and how much effort the raider will make to reach him. This reminds me of old tapes. In 2026, Iran's Fazel Atrachali worked like this. His reach was so good that he was always ready to 'stop' any raider. And do you know that Atrachali's record for tackle points in PKL still stands? This is not just a coincidence. It is a lesson. When India plays in this tournament, it must understand that its greatest talent is in raiding, but its greatest danger is in defense. If it is alert this time, gold is certain. If not, Jakarta could repeat itself. One more thing — I want to avoid the disease of the 'first-timer.' When a country hosts an event for the first time, newspapers often write details in excitement. But my job is to break the process of excitement. This championship has 62 matches, 39 men's and 23 women's. That's a huge number. But it doesn't mean the sport is expanding. It means there will be many weak matches, and Indian fans will get tired. I saw in the 2026 Commonwealth Games that many sports had weak participating countries. Yet the event was declared 'successful.' I am not saying expansion is bad — I am saying look at expansion with honesty. Starting with a Kenya-Singapore match is good, but this match will not be remembered longer than any India match. So who is this event for? For the players? Or for the organizers? I now come to the final part. This tournament will run until October 31, with matches, finals, and a champion. But the real question is whether this championship will prove to be a new beginning for Indian kabaddi, or is this the same old story — India wins, and the world watches? I have already said that the 2026 semifinal (18-27 against Iran in Jakarta) was not a 'betrayal,' but mathematics. Here too, we must see if there are upsets in the group stage. For example, if England beats India in the men's category, that would be the first big shock. The possibility is low, but I cannot dismiss it. The beauty of kabaddi is that everything can change in one moment. So when I write about the sport, I don't just think about teams, but about possibilities. And possibilities sometimes arise from the weakest team. One big miss of this tournament is that the media will only sell the 'India vs. the World' story

Not an Inaugural Sacrifice, a Record Cleanse: The Commonwealth Kabaddi in Ahmedabad is an Indian Tactic, Not a Sport Expansion

Not an Inaugural Sacrifice, a Record Cleanse: The Commonwealth Kabaddi in Ahmedabad is an Indian Tactic, Not a Sport Expansion

Not an Inaugural Sacrifice, a Record Cleanse: The Commonwealth Kabaddi in Ahmedabad is an Indian Tactic, Not a Sport Expansion

संबंधित खिलाड़ी